The Midyear Plot Twist: Why Your “Imperfect” Progress Is More Than Enough

Today we hit the year’s exact midpoint — 182 days behind us, 182 days ahead. As Melissa Kirsch writes in The New York TimesJuly 2nd is an opportune moment to look back at where you’ve been, and to set your sights on where you want to go.

Perhaps your first half wasn’t perfect. Don’t worry. Perfect has never been the point.

The Paradox of Looking Back to Move Forward

There’s something counterintuitive about reflection that most people miss: the best way to create meaningful progress isn’t to look ahead—it’s to pause and honestly examine where you’ve been.

This isn’t about dwelling in the past or getting stuck in analysis paralysis. It’s about mining your recent experiences for the kind of intelligence that can’t be found in any productivity hack or life optimization framework. Your own patterns of thriving, stumbling, and recovering contain more wisdom about your path forward than any external blueprint ever could.

Research backs this up. Studies on “implementation intentions” show that people who regularly reflect on their progress are significantly more likely to achieve their goals than those who simply set targets and charge ahead. But here’s the twist: the most effective reflection isn’t about cataloging failures or obsessing over what went wrong. It’s about identifying what worked, what drained you, and what patterns deserve more of your attention.

What follows are four evidence-based strategies for reflection that don’t just help you feel good about the past—they give you actionable intelligence for designing a more intentional future.

1. Celebrate Your Progress (Even the Imperfect Kind)

Here’s something psychologists have known for decades but most of us conveniently ignore: progress, not perfection, is what actually drives sustained motivation. Research from Harvard Business School’s Teresa Amabile shows that of all the factors that can boost emotions, motivation, and perceptions during a workday, the single most important is making progress in meaningful work—even if that progress feels incremental.

Try this: Name one thing you’ve accomplished this year that genuinely lifted your spirits, regardless of whether it’s “complete.” Maybe you finally started that meditation practice (even if you’ve only managed three sessions), or sent a thank you letter for two Christmas presents, or shifted how you talk to yourself after setbacks.

Progress is psychological fuel, and it works even when it’s messy, inconsistent, or still unfolding. The key insight from decades of motivation research is this: our brains are wired to respond to forward movement, not finish lines.

Dig deeper: What specific strength or value helped you make this progress? Was it persistence? Curiosity? The willingness to ask for help? Understanding your success patterns isn’t just feel-good reflection—it’s strategic intelligence for future challenges.

Remember: perfect has never been the enemy of good. It’s the enemy of getting started.

2. Practice Strategic Subtraction

While most self-help advice pushes addition—more goals, more habits, more optimization—behavioral scientists increasingly point to subtraction as the secret sauce for sustainable change. Research from the University of Virginia shows we have a systematic bias toward adding rather than removing, even when subtraction would be more effective.

Try this: Identify two things you need to release that no longer serve your wellbeing or growth. This might be a limiting belief that’s kept you playing small, a role you’ve outgrown but keep clinging to, or an impossible standard that’s quietly draining your energy.

The neuroscience here is fascinating: our brains treat letting go as a form of loss, triggering the same neural pathways as physical pain. But here’s what’s remarkable—when we consciously choose what to release, we’re not just clearing mental space. We’re practicing what psychologists call “cognitive flexibility,” one of the strongest predictors of resilience and life satisfaction.

3. Architect Your Social Ecosystem

The Framingham Heart Study, spanning over 70 years and three generations, revealed something extraordinary: happiness spreads through social networks up to three degrees of separation. Your friend’s friend’s friend can literally influence your wellbeing. Yet most of us treat relationships like afterthoughts, waiting for our schedules to “make room” for connection.

Try this: Think of three relationships that have been particularly life-enhancing this year. How can you nurture them more intentionally? This isn’t about networking or transactional relationship-building—it’s about recognizing that psychological thriving happens in community.

The research is unambiguous: people with strong social connections live longer, recover from illness faster, and report higher life satisfaction than those who prioritize individual achievement alone. Harvard’s Grant Study, following subjects for over 80 years, concluded that the quality of our relationships is the strongest predictor of life satisfaction.

Take action: Reach out, check in, make plans, listen with your full attention. Happiness comes from “with” just as much as it comes from within. Your wellbeing is fundamentally relational.

4. Follow Your Energy Intelligence

Energy, it turns out, is information. Positive psychology research shows that the moments when we feel most energized are reliable indicators of our core strengths and values in action. When we ignore these signals, we’re essentially ignoring our internal GPS for a meaningful life.

Try this: Identify four specific moments this year when you felt genuinely energized and expansive. What were you doing? Who were you with? What elements can you intentionally replicate?

This isn’t about chasing constant high energy or avoiding all challenges. Research from the University of Rochester on “eudaimonic wellbeing” shows that sustainable energy comes from activities that align with our authentic selves and contribute to something beyond personal gain.

The strategic insight: Those moments when you felt most energized aren’t random—they’re data points revealing your personal strengths and values in action. Think of them as breadcrumbs marking the trail toward work, relationships, and activities that genuinely suit who you are. The more you deliberately seek out experiences that mirror these high-energy moments, the more you’ll find yourself living in alignment with what actually matters to you, rather than what you think should matter.

From Insight to Action

Here’s what I’ve learned from years of studying wellbeing research: reflection without action is just sophisticated procrastination. The insights you’ve just uncovered—your progress patterns, the things you need to release, the relationships that fuel you, and the activities that genuinely energize you—are only valuable if they change how you show up tomorrow.

The most successful people aren’t those who set the most ambitious goals or follow the most elaborate systems. They’re the ones who pay attention to what their own experience is teaching them and have the courage to act on those insights, even when they contradict conventional wisdom or societal expectations or even gut feelings.

So take these reflections seriously. Put them somewhere you’ll see them. Let them inform your decisions in the weeks ahead. Because the gap between insight and action is where most good intentions go to die—and where the most meaningful transformations begin.

Your life is happening right now, not when you finally figure everything out. These four practices aren’t preparation for living well; they are living well. The question isn’t whether you’ll be perfect at implementing them. The question is whether you’ll be brave enough to start.

You’re constantly changing, whether you acknowledge it or not. As Taylor Swift reminds us in her song Dear Reader, “If you don’t recognize yourself, that means you did it right.”

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

How to Support a Friend Who Is Having a Hard Time

What is the best way to support a friend in need? According to research, this may be the wrong question. Simply showing up and expressing warmth and love is what matters most. The study, Too Reluctant to Reach Out: Receiving Social Support Is More Positive Than Expressers Expect published in Psychological Science found that all too often we hesitate to express support because we worry too much about saying or doing the “right thing” and question our competence to provide what the person needs.

According to the study, there is a gap between how expressers and recipients perceive the very same supportive act. Expressers tend to focus on how effectively they are supporting another person whereas recipients tend to focus on the warmth and kindness that they receive. As a result of the mismatch, we systematically miss opportunities to help others more in daily life:

“Each day offers opportunities to reach out and show some form of support, however large or small, to a person in need. Our experiments suggest that undervaluing the positive impact of expressing support could create a psychological barrier to expressing it more often. Withholding support because of misguided fears of saying or doing the wrong thing could leave both recipients and expressers less happy than they could be,” explained the researchers.

When in doubt, send that text, make that phone call and show up. It means more than you realize.

Fans of The West Wing may remember the iconic scene when Leo McGarry tells his friend, Josh Lyman, the story about the man in the hole. Josh is having a hard time and Leo shares these words of wisdom:

“This guy’s walking down the street when he falls in a hole. The walls are so steep he cant get out.

A doctor passes by and the guy shouts up, ‘Hey you. Can you help me out?’ The doctor writes a prescription, throws it down in the hole and moves on.

Then a priest comes along and the guy shouts up, ‘Father, I’m down in this hole, can you help me out?’ The priest writes out a prayer, throws it down in the hole and moves on.

Then a friend walks by, ‘Hey, Joe, it’s me can you help me out?’ And the friend jumps into the hole. Our guy says, ‘Are you stupid? Now we’re both down here.’ The friend says, ‘Yeah, but I’ve been down here before and I know the way out.'”

Simply being there for someone is an act of grace. As Cecilia Irene reflected on her blog, “Leo’s quotation is the definition of love and friendship. Prayer is infinitely valuable. Medicine is good. But sometimes what you really need is for someone to meet you where you are and try to help you climb out of the pit.”

The Man in the Hole story reminds me of a beautiful letter poet Robert Lowell wrote to his fellow poet John Berryman who was going through a rough patch:

“I have been thinking much about you all summer, and how we have gone through the same troubles, visiting the bottom of the world. I have wanted to stretch out a hand, and tell you that I have been there too, and how it all lightens and life swims back … “

Don’t let agonizing over finding the right words or doing the right thing keep you from expressing warmth and love. Reach out to others in need more often and remind them that life swims back.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

It’s Time to Stop Fixating on Your Feelings

Take a moment and think about your right big toe.

Focus on it. Straighten it. Wiggle it.

Now ask: how does it feel? Snug in your sock? Slightly pinched in your shoe?

You likely hadn’t noticed it up until this moment unless of course you have gout or recently stubbed it. But now that you’re paying attention, your right big toe is taking up prime real estate in your mind and is impossible to ignore.

Attention is a spotlight

What seems like a psychological trick is actually a demonstration of how attention works. Our brains are amazing filtering machines, adept at cancelling out huge amounts of stimuli that would otherwise be too much to handle at once. It’s only when we shine a spotlight on something (in this case the big toe) that it enters awareness. And what we focus on determines what we experience. The more we concentrate on something, the larger it looms.

A study conducted at Stanford University’s School of Medicine asked participants to hold a thermal wand that gradually increased in heat to cause mild discomfort. The result? Those who distracted themselves, by thinking about someone they loved or played word games, reported significantly less pain than those who fixated on how their hand felt.

The same is true for our emotions. If you don’t focus on your anger, it’s hard to stay angry. If you don’t fixate on what’s bothering you, it’s hard to stay bothered. As William James famously wrote, “my experience is what I agree to attend to.”

There is nothing wrong with feeling your feelings. What I am concerned about is fixating on them. When we pay attention to difficult feelings, they usually grow rather than diminish. It’s like fertilizing a weed. And yet, this is exactly what we have been told to do if we want to improve our mental health. When you think about it, that’s exactly what some forms of therapy do.

A study conducted at Stanford University’s School of Medicine asked participants to hold a thermal wand that gradually increased in heat to cause mild discomfort. The result? Those who distracted themselves, by thinking about someone they loved or played word games, reported significantly less pain than those who fixated on how their hand felt.

The same is true for our emotions. If you don’t focus on your anger, it’s hard to stay angry. If you don’t fixate on what’s bothering you, it’s hard to stay bothered. As William James famously wrote, “my experience is what I agree to attend to.”

There is nothing wrong with feeling your feelings. What I am concerned about is fixating on them. When we pay attention to difficult feelings, they usually grow rather than diminish. It’s like fertilizing a weed. And yet, this is exactly what we have been told to do if we want to improve our mental health. When you think about it, that’s exactly what some forms of therapy do.

What mentally strong people do differently

In my experience, mentally strong people do not spend countless hours exploring and understanding themselves. They are not trying to “find” themselves. Alas, nobody I know has ever actually found themselves and in my humble opinion … that’s a good thing. It means we are all evolving.

Talking about what’s bothering you may be helpful at times but not if it allows you to back away from reality or to avoid taking action. As therapist David K. Reynolds said, “continued complaining only makes us skillful complainers.” The truth is you don’t need to understand your feelings to get on with your life.

I have found that the most well-adjusted people do two things:

1. They accept—instead of dwelling on—their feelings.

They recognize that feelings go away unless we feed them. They don’t deny or hide from their pain, they just don’t allow it to dictate their lives.

2. They do things.

Their behavior is purposeful and deliberate. They recognize that they cannot control what’s going on in their head but they can control what actions they take. They are responsible for their behaviors regardless of how they feel.

Feelings don’t excuse behavior

All too often we use our feelings as an excuse.

  • “I can’t ask for what I want because I’m anxious.”
  • “I raised my voice because I was angry.”
  • “I didn’t listen because I was distracted.”

The word “because” is not a defense, nor is it an explanation. Plain and simple: It’s a rationalization. Not asking for what one wants, raising one’s voice, and not listening are all choices. We have become emotional gluttons, overly relying on our emotions to guide us. There is nothing wrong with feeling your feelings, just don’t give them the microphone.

Bottom Line:

Don’t endure unpleasant circumstances that can be changed by action. Feelings are for feeling. Not for explaining, for justifying, or for acting out.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

How Boomerasking Steals the Magic of Good Conversation

“Hey, how was your weekend?” the person asks you. You respond that it was fine. Then the person launches into a sermon about all the cool things they did. “Mine was amazing! So on Friday my son won his karate tournament, on Saturday I competed in an Iron Man, and then on Sunday I perfected my croissant-making skills.” What initially seemed like a genuine interest in you suddenly shifts course and becomes an opportunity for the other person to talk about themselves.

If this conversation sequence sounds familiar, you have encountered a boomerasker–someone who asks a question, lets the other person answer, and then answers the question themselves. Like a boomerang, the question returns quickly to its source. As the old saying goes, and boomerasking encapsulates, most people don’t listen to understand, they listen to reply.

According to a study published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology, there are three main categories of boomerasking:

1. Ask-bragging

This type of boomerasker likes to outdo you.

They ask you a question and then follow with a show-off response as described above.

2. Ask-complaining

This type of boomerasker likes to out-vent you.

When they ask you a question such as, “How was your day?” and you respond with a simple “long.” They then follow up with “Tell me about it! You think your day was tough–my day was brutal. Between the kids, my clients, and my husband, there is no time for me.”

3. Ask-sharing

This type of boomerasker feigns interest in your opinion but has already made up their mind and has been waiting to share it with you.

When the person asks you a question such as “What should we eat for dinner tonight?” You respond, “How about pizza.” They respond with, “Let’s have tacos. I know the best place to order from.”

We have all been on the receiving end of a boomerask. Truth be told, it is likely that we have also been a boomerasker. In the study, more than 90 percent of respondents acknowledged that they had asked and been asked a boomerasker-type question. Full disclosure, I was out with friends the evening after the Blue Origin flight and asked the group, “So what did you all think of the space flight?” Yes, I was curious about everyone’s opinion but I also couldn’t wait to weigh in myself. Perhaps this is a subtype of boomerasking: ask-opining?

The problem with boomerasking is that it ruins the magic of a good conversation. Failing to follow up on your partner’s answer, and answering the question yourself makes the person feel like you don’t care about them—and probably didn’t care about them when you asked the question in the first place. It was just an excuse for you to hijack the conversation and talk about yourself.

While research shows that talking about oneself feels good (yes, this is one of the reasons why so many people love therapy), there is good evidence that if we care about strengthening our social bonds, asking sincere questions, genuinely listening to others’ responses, and following up on those responses with care and curiosity is the way to go. As the authors of the study conclude:

Communicators who ask sincere questions and listen to their partners’ answers can uncover deeper, more supportive conversations and relationships, but people should avoid turning the focus of a conversation back to themselves before showing interest in their partner’s answer.

The people who listen to us are the ones we move toward. When we feel heard, we expand. When we feel dismissed, we retreat. Good manners have a role to play here. As my mother always told me, “Whatever you do, don’t talk too much about yourself.” Put simply, focus on the other person. Show interest in them before proving how interesting you are to them.

A Cure for Popcorn Brain

“I feel so scattered,” explained Ava. Like many people I know, my patient Ava was having a hard time focusing. “I open my phone to check the weather but then a notification pops up about some infuriating political news so I check X, and then open Instagram, and then I get a message from my mom but before I reply, my friend sends me a link to a celebrity scandal, and I quickly check the status of my Amazon order. By the time I finally put my phone down and try to get back to work, I realize I never got around to checking the weather. My attention is all over the place.”

What Ava is describing is “popcorn brain,” a term coined by David Levy, a researcher at the University of Washington, to describe a shortened attention span and the experience of overstimulation. Like popping corn kernels in a pot, attention jumps from one thought to the next. Popcorn brain is characterized by diminished focus, heightened stress, fatigue, information overload, attentional deficit issues, increased anxiety, and an overall detrimental impact on relationships and quality of life. Sound familiar?

The cognitive disarray caused by popcorn brain is exhausting and makes it hard to get anything done. Thankfully a study published in PNAS Nexus offers a simple solution: spend less time online. Researchers found that people who blocked internet access on their cellphones for just two weeks reported significant improvements in mood and ability to focus. Ninety one percent of people who tried the two-week detox said they felt meaningfully better. The study only restricted internet access on their phones, so participants were still able to text and make calls. If they wanted to read the news, online shop or check social media, they could from an iPad or laptop. In other words, they were not totally cut off from the internet, it just wasn’t in the palm of their hand. Constant connection has its costs.

 

Attention, mental health, and SWB improve after 2 weeks of blocking mobile internet. In the Intervention group, participants blocked mobile internet access from T1 to T2. In the Delayed Intervention group, participants blocked mobile internet access from T2 to T3.

 

Even the people who did not fully adhere to the rules of the intervention experienced significant improvements in mental health, wellbeing, and focus. The analysis suggests that the benefits can be partially explained by the intervention’s impact on how participants spent their time. When they did not have access to mobile internet, they spent more time doing other things like talking to other people, exercising, and being in nature. Simply put, when endless scrolling wasn’t an option, participants looked up from their phones and engaged in other-oriented and outer-oriented activities.

The researchers summed the benefits of this simple intervention:

Blocking mobile internet for 2 weeks reduces smartphone use and improves subjective well-being including life satisfaction and positive affect, mental health more than antidepressants, and sustained attention as much as being 10 years younger. Despite the many benefits mobile internet offers, reducing the constant connection to the digital world can have large positive effects.

I have told everyone I know about this life enhancing study. While impressed with the results, nobody has said, “I cannot wait to try it. I’m starting tomorrow!” What gets between knowing what will make us feel better and actually doing what will make us feel better? Motivation, habit, and instant gratification are certainly factors. In my experience, collective action is one of the biggest impediments to behavior change. If nobody else is doing it, it’s hard to be the lone ranger. So instead of going it alone, loop in your friends and family. Try a week of everyone turning off access to mobile internet and see how you feel in seven days.

Let me know if your popcorn brain simmers down…

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

How to Cut the Risk of Depression in Half

We all know that eating well, getting enough sleep, and exercise is good for our health. A Cambridge University study published in the British Journal of Psychiatry highlights an arguably more fun way to give ourselves a boost: going out on the town. While I am not suggesting you become a club rat, there is evidence that a night out may be just what the doctor ordered.

Researchers examined data collected from 2000 British adults over age 50 over a 10 year period. After analyzing data on their health and lifestyle, a clear pattern emerged. When people go out to enjoy a movie, show, or museum on a regular basis, their chance of becoming depressed plummets. Just one outing every few months was enough to cut their risk of depression by 32 percent. Those who went out once a month or more cut their risk of depression by nearly half. Given how down people are these days, that’s saying something. While it is unclear what exactly it is about cultural engagement that protects against depression, it is likely a combination of factors including social interaction, mental creativity, cognitive stimulation, and the gentle physical activity of just getting there.

I recently attended a concert in NYC and truth be told, it was terrible. It was a band I had loved from the 90s but 30 years later they were a little tragic. That said, there was something fun about the experience. I looked forward to going beforehand, I loved being with my friends at the event, and we laughed later about how awful it was. The social component looms large. I cannot help but think that social connection is what makes cultural engagement so protective against depression.

Dr. Gregg Henriques of James Madison University has argued that depression is a state of behavioral shutdown. When a person is feeling low, their knee jerk response is often avoidance and withdrawal. This unlocks a downward spiral of critical thoughts and an inner battle leaving the person even more stressed, isolated, and depleted. The only way to counteract Shutdown Syndrome, Henriques argues, is to harness what he calls the “paradox of effort.” Put simply, override the impulse to avoid and withdraw and instead deliberately participate in activities that move you toward your values, that boost positive emotions, and that enhance connection.

Avoidance may feel like the most natural response in the world, especially when it’s 12 degrees outside and everything seems upside down but withdrawing will never pull you out of the cave. If anything, it will make it colder and darker. Think of cultural engagement as a way out of the cave and as an antidote to Shutdown Syndrome.

Override the temptation to retreat. Ignore the allure of another night at home in front of the television. Make plans with a friend to do something and stick to them. We are often told that what we feel shapes what we do. But it goes both ways. What we do also shapes how we feel. Choose activities that engage you and connect you to others.

A dose of awe

Last week I went to see Caspar David Friedrich: The Soul of Nature at the Metropolitan Museum. It took my breath away. His vision of landscape is at once meditative, mysterious, and full of wonder.

Here is his iconic painting Wanderer above the Sea of Fog. The title captures the mood of how pretty much everyone I know feels at this moment.

About this work, Friedrich wrote, “It reminds me how small I am, but also how miraculous this life is.”

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman