Q+A | Whenever I’m in a bad mood, people always tell me to let it go. How do I do this?

Question:
When I’m in a bad mood, people always tell me I have to let it go. How do I do that?


Answer:
Elsa in the film
Frozen is probably the only person who has ever benefitted from that empty phrase. Apologies to Disney, but telling someone to “let it go” is counter-productive for three reasons:
  1. It implies that it’s possible to snap your fingers or wiggle your nose and move past whatever is bothering you.

  2. It assumes that all negative emotions are problematic.

  3. It can make a bad mood even worse.

Instead of trying to “let it go,” when you find yourself in a bad mood, try to pinpoint exactly what is bothering you and describe your feelings as precisely as you can. Are you frustrated? Disheartened? Despondent? Exasperated? Instead of resigning yourself to a generalized negative mood for the next few hours, put a label on your emotions. Break out a thesaurus if necessary.

People who are able to differentiate their negative emotions are better at regulating and managing them, according to science. Rather than being consumed by a general feeling of malaise, differentiators are more action oriented. Knowing what is wrong empowers them to seek a solution and tailor a response to the situation. For example, recognizing that you felt flustered after a disagreement with a colleague might prompt you to speak to the manager or go for a walk outside. Feeling “bad” doesn’t provide you with the same kind of useful information. It just hovers over you like a cloud. And because it is so vague, it can easily spill into other aspects of your life and be the reason you snap at your partner later that day.

People who struggle with emotion differentiation are more likely to feel overwhelmed and helpless. They may also be more vulnerable to unhealthy or unfocused responses like binge drinking or physical aggression. Distressing feelings are more likely to dominate their attention and dictate how they behave.

The good news is that emotional differentiation is a skill that can be learned and deployed on a daily basis.

By expanding your emotional vocabulary, you are giving yourself the tools to label and understand an array of nuanced emotional states. Not only will your bad moods feel less potent, you will be better equipped to handle negativity when it arises. Plus, “Let it go,” will be a phrase you are only subjected to in a movie.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

People Like You More Than You Know

If making conversation after months of isolation feels awkward, you are not alone. “I’m at a loss for words. I just don’t know what to say,” explained one friend. “The only thing I talk about is what I’m watching on Netflix. Not exactly riveting conversation,” lamented another.

Bob Morris perfectly captured the uncanny awkwardness of socializing in a recent New York Times article.

“Jumping back into pleasant interactions can feel like returning from a year in the wilderness, a silent meditation retreat or outer space.”

Feeling like a social alien is driving some people to keep to themselves even as restrictions ease. While avoidance shields you from the anxiety of in-person interactions in the short term, it is not a healthy long term solution. For starters, avoidance typically begets avoidance. The more you keep your distance, the more isolated you will feel and the harder it becomes to reconnect.

Decades of research in psychology has shown that the most effective way to disrupt the anxiety-avoidance loop is to confront the anxiety provoking situation head on. This is known as exposure therapy. If someone is terrified of flying, they can avoid air travel altogether but if they want to get over that fear, they need to face it. Treatment for aerophobia often involves exposure through imagined flights, virtual reality, flight simulation, and actual flying.

The key to rebuilding rusty social skills is not to become a recluse but to expose yourself to social situations, albeit awkward ones.

The truth is most people feel like awkward eighth graders at their first dance right now. It’s perfectly normal to feel socially inept after months of isolation.

If you worry about not being witty or charming enough, take heart. A study found that we systematically underestimate how much our conversation partners like us and enjoy our company.

The liking gap exposes the gulf between what we think someone else thinks and what they actually think. After a social interaction, our internal monologues can be remarkably self-critical and negative:

“I bet she thinks I’m a crashing bore?”
“Why did I bring up politics?”
“Was I too nosy?”
“Why did I tell that story?”

The ticker tape of self-doubt distorts perception, leaving us feeling unlikable and uninteresting. In reality, people judge us less harshly than we judge ourselves. In fact, the study suggests that after people have a conversation, they are liked more than they realize.

Conversations are a powerful source of connection. As the authors observe, “Conversations have the power to turn strangers into friends, coffee dates into marriages, and job interviews into jobs.” So, don’t shy away from talking to others. It might take a little while to feel normal in social situations again but the more you do it, the more natural it will become. And remember, the people you interact with will like you more than you know.

Here are some ice-breakers to get a conversation going:

“What was your greatest challenge during this past year?”
“What did you learn?”
“What are you looking forward to?”
“Acquired any interesting new interesting skills or neuroses since last year?”

 

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

What Makes People Feel Better During Tough Times?

What enables people to stay strong during periods of stress and uncertainty? An enormous study conducted across 87 countries and involving 20,000 participants during the pandemic identified a simple coping strategy that helped people feel better: cognitive reappraisal. Cognitive reappraisal entails reframing how you think about a given situation. For example, some participants in the study were given the following directions:

“This strategy is based on the insight that finding something good in even the most challenging situations can lead to different emotional responses. This means that refocusing on whatever good aspects may be found in a situation can change how you feel about the situation. For example, consider someone who stays at home under lockdown due to COVID-19 and is feeling anxious, sad, or angry. In this case, refocusing might involve realizing that staying at home gives them time to do things that they may not have been able to do before, like reading, painting, and spending time with family.”


The type of cognitive reappraisal above is asking, “What can I learn from this situation?” Other reappraisal techniques include “What would you tell a friend in the same situation?” or “How would your future self describe the current situation?” Cognitive reappraisal enables us to develop a more balanced perspective and to think more flexibly. Rather than tumbling down a rabbit hole of catastrophizing and negative thoughts, it asks us to pause and consider other possible interpretations. Essentially, when we engage in cognitive reappraisal, we are thinking like a detective, generating alternative explanations instead of clinging to a distorted doom and gloom knee-jerk response.

Research shows that the secret sauce of cognitive reappraisal is that it reduces negative emotions and increases positive emotions and, that the presence of positive emotions during trying times is strongly linked with resilience. For example, a study following the terrorist attacks of September 11th, 2001 showed that positive emotions were a key active ingredient that enabled resilient individuals to ward off depression.

The idea that it is possible to experience positive emotions in the midst of chronic stress may at first seem counterintuitive but the reality is that many people do experience these emotions even in the most dire of circumstances. Feelings of love, hope, and gratitude can coexist alongside distress, frustration, and boredom. Cognitive reappraisal is a tool that can help you avoid depleting negative spirals, and more importantly, unearth resilience-building uplifting emotions.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

What’s the Best Way to Motivate Someone Who Lacks Motivation?

For years, I offered trusty advice to my children about how to achieve academic success. I worked my tail off in school and thought of myself as a treasure trove of information. Convinced that my words of wisdom would light their scholarly fire, I would go on for hours about how to develop good study habits. Perhaps seeing their eyes glaze over as I banged on about the benefits of working hard and doing their best should have alerted me to the possibility that the message might not be sinking in.

So, what does help? Research from the University of Pennsylvania offers a counterintuitive solution. Instead of giving students expert advice about how to do well in school as I had been doing ad nauseam, ask them to provide advice to other students about how to do well. In the study, middle school students (6th, 7th, and 8th graders) who shared their thoughts about why school matters with 4th graders became more motivated to study vocabulary themselves.

A different group of middle schoolers received advice from teachers on how to become better students. The teachers’ tips were objectively sound but didn’t impact behavior. Contrary to the assumption of well-meaning parents and teachers everywhere, explaining to children why and how they should study doesn’t make much of a difference. Most children are fully aware of optimal study habits. They don’t need more information. What they need is motivation.

Being a giver turns out to be a wellspring of motivation. Instead of being a struggling student in need of help, when you give advice, you become a competent person capable of providing help. Plus, human beings like to be consistent. When advocating for an idea, you take ownership of it. In the process of telling another person about how important something is, you remind yourself of its importance too.

Next time you encounter someone who is having trouble reaching a goal, save your breath. Instead of offering your words of wisdom, ask them to offer their words of wisdom to someone in a similar predicament.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

Autumn Anxiety is Real

Autumn anxiety may not be an official diagnosis but the annual experience of increased stress at this time of year is very real. As seasons go, fall is cited by many of my patients as the most stressful. The end of summer, a new school year, a more rigid schedule, and the impending holidays all contribute to autumn anxiety. Concerns about the delta variant are making the transition this year especially challenging.

Here are five strategies to help you stay strong within this stressful season:

  1. Just because the summer is over does not mean it is time to hibernate. Spend as much time as you can outdoors. Being in nature reduces rumination and has a calming effect on the body and mind. If possible, walk your child to school. Walking to school has been shown to improve students’ focus and behavior and will give your morning a boost too.
  2. How you talk about accomplishing tasks can impact how you feel about them. Saying “I have to finish the project” implies an obligation and that you are working on the project because it is expected of you. Consider saying instead, “I want to finish the project.” Not only will you be more likely to complete the project when you tap in your intrinsic motivation, the process will be more enjoyable.
  3. Make healthy habits a family value. Model the behavior you want to encourage. Eat the fruits and vegetables you serve to your kids. Take the stairs instead of the elevator. Make sleep a priority for everyone. Everyone will be happier, healthier, and less stressed.
  4. As tempting as it is to withdraw from others and to retreat into oneself when feeling overwhelmed, excessive self-focus tends to amplify stress. Remember to look outside yourself for connection and inspiration. Look up from your phone. Make plans with friends. Lend a hand to someone in need. Doing things with and for others is resilience-building. Even small gestures like opening a door for a stranger, holding the elevator, bringing a co-worker coffee, or telling your partner how much you appreciate them can help mitigate autumn anxiety. Making an effort, even when you least feel like it, will fortify you.
  5. Resist the urge to fill every afternoon with after school activities and allow for some downtime instead. Encourage your kids to keep themselves busy and to fill free time by coming up with their own games. In addition to boosting their creativity and ability to take initiative, you will benefit from not having to shuttle them to yet another after school practice.

Albert Camus observed, “autumn is a second spring where every leaf is a flower” but not everyone shares his excitement for the season. Transitions often cause anxiety and the transition this year from summer to fall is extra stressful for many people. Whatever you do, don’t admire the autumn leaves as they fall from your iPhone screen. Go and see the real thing.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman

Thinking Positively Won’t Get You Closer to Your Goals

Thinking positive thoughts or wishing for good things to happen is unlikely to lead to constructive change or transformation. As I write about in Everyday Vitality, without taking steps to mobilize what we care about and to embody our values, our dreams will stay where they started–in our head.

New York University professor of psychology Gabriele Oettingen has found that people who spend time envisioning how good it will feel to reach a goal without taking any concrete actions toward it are less likely to achieve it. In a study of obese women who enrolled in a weight-loss plan, Oettingen found that women who had positive fantasies about their weight loss—such as showing off their new body to a friend who had not seen them in a year, or supposing that it would be easy to resist a leftover box of doughnuts—were less likely to lose weight than those who were realistic about the challenges they faced.

Oettingen found a similar pattern across multiple domains, including quitting smoking, starting a relationship, doing well on an exam, and getting a job. Fantasizing about being successful without actually pursuing it also undermined motivation. Dreaming turns out to be devitalizing. In fact, participants in a study who were asked to generate positive fantasies about the week ahead felt less energized and later reported poor accomplishment and lower mastery of everyday challenges. Moreover, they were less likely to put in the effort and persist when setbacks occurred. Oettingen theorizes that “mentally attaining” what you want obscures the actual need to apply the effort to make it happen.

Mental Contrasting

Instead of fantasizing, try mental contrasting, which combines being optimistic with being realistic. Mental contrasting means imagining a positive outcome while recognizing the potential obstacles involved and planning actions to overcome them. Based on her research about mental contrasting, Oettingen recommends setting what she calls WOOP goals to close the gap between one’s present reality and desired future.

The four steps are as follows:
1. Imagine something meaningful and important to you that can be attained within a specific time frame. Put the goal into words.
Examples: “I want to do well on my math test.” “I want to feel more gratitude while living my life.”
2. How would you feel? Imagine feeling this way and put it into words.
Examples: “I would feel deeply engaged in my work.” “I would feel proud of myself.” “I would feel tremendous relief.”
3. Consider what can hold you back from achieving what you wish for. Say it to yourself or put it into words.
Examples: “I have a hard time saying no.” “I get distracted by social media.” “I am always exhausted.” “I am a procrastinator.”
4. What is an executive action you can take to tackle this obstacle? Make what is known as an implementation intention (aka: an action plan) to confront the obstacle when it arises.
Example: “If someone offers me a drink, I will say, ‘No, Thank You.'” “If I get distracted by my phone when I am with my family in the evening, I will leave it on my desk.” “If I feel like eating junk food, I will go for a walk around the block.”
Mental contrasting has been found to be an effective technique with stressed-out college kids at increasing their physical activity, and with helping people to make healthier choices about what to eat. Students improved their grades and time management using WOOP. Nurses who performed a daily WOOP exercise to reduce work stress reported psychological and physical symptoms and increased vigor and engagement after three weeks.
WOOP may sound like a silly acronym but it’s a powerful tool.

I wish you all the best,

Dr. Samantha Boardman